New York City FC
3 - 2
Cincinnati
New York City FC
Cincinnati
Mitja Ilenic
Kevin Kelsy
James Sands
Yamil Asad
Teenage Hadebe
Ian Murphy
Alvas Powell
Alonso Martinez
Thiago Martins Bueno
Luciano Federico Acosta
Andres Perea(Penalty awarded)
Santiago Rodriguez
Monsef Bakrar
Alonso Martinez
Nicholas Gioacchini
Yuya Kubo
Corey Baird
Lucas Orellano
Andres Perea
Tayvon Gray
Mitja Ilenic
Birk Risa
Maximiliano Moralez
Kipp Keller
DeAndre Yedlin
Tayvon Gray
Corey Baird
Strahinja Tanasijevic
Santiago Rodriguez
Hannes Wolf